⭐ Cometly vs Improvely vs Keitaro

Cometly is a powerful marketing attribution software trusted by over 2,000 businesses, offering hyper-accurate ad attribution that enables marketing teams to measure and prove ROI confidently.

With its comprehensive features and intuitive interface, the platform streamlines ad tracking, optimizes campaigns, and provides real-time visualizations of marketing performance.

By reducing wasted ad spend and identifying profitable channels, Cometly helps businesses allocate their marketing budget more efficiently and craft captivating ads for increased revenue.

Joining Cometly's community of advertisers offers supportive growth opportunities and a time-saving, automated reporting process.

However, larger businesses might find the pricing structure costlier, and some features and tracking capabilities are still limited.

Read the full Cometly Review

👉 Visit Cometly

Improvely is a powerful platform that enhances online marketing strategies by tracking, optimizing, and safeguarding campaigns.

Its intuitive dashboard simplifies tracking and attribution, while vigilant click fraud monitoring protects ad budgets.

The platform's attribution system aids in precise optimization, and activity profiling offers deeper insights into valuable customers.

Improvely accommodates collaboration, compatibility with major platforms, and offers a 14-day free trial.

Despite some subscription costs and setup complexity, Improvely stands out for its comprehensive marketing analytics, access control, and fraud prevention, making it a valuable tool for marketing excellence.

Read the full Improvely Review

👉 Visit Improvely

Keitaro™ is a powerful advertising tracker designed for media buyers and publishers in the affiliate marketing industry.

With over 120 integrated traffic sources, it offers minute-to-minute data updates, customizable reports, and efficient conversions attribution, leading to cost reduction and better decision-making.

Notable features include traffic distribution on user terms, multi-offer landing pages, and GDPR compliance.

Users praise its seamless integration, protection from bots, and advertising optimization capabilities.

While it lacks a mobile app and has a learning curve, Keitaro remains a comprehensive and reliable solution, offering wide functionality and competitive pricing in the performance marketing landscape.

Read the full Keitaro Review

👉 Visit Keitaro

The target audience for Cometly is marketing teams and ad managers who seek a powerful marketing attribution software, that provides accurate revenue attribution from ads, real-time insights, and automated reporting, enabling them to optimize campaigns, allocate marketing budget efficiently, and scale successful ads for improved ROI and business growth.

The target audience for Improvely is online marketers, advertisers, and agencies looking to track their marketing efforts, optimize conversions, and monitor click fraud to protect their advertising budgets.

The target audience for Keitaro is media buyers and publishers in the affiliate and performance marketing industry.

• Easy and user-friendly setup.
• Free trial with a meeting to fix the strategy.
• Unlimited users and workspaces.
• Robust analysis and offers a breakdown of day-to-day performance.
• Unaffected by iOS 14 and later blockage.
• Tracking with Comet Pixel.
• Easy to use Conversion API.
• Similar features available for all plans.
• Integrates with Shopify, Meta, and most other popular native ad platforms.
• Sends data back to Facebook via the Conversion API.
• Accurate tracking.
• Beautiful interface.
• Pricing by ad budget.
• Can track any type of store.
• Good customer support.

• Comprehensive Marketing Analytics: Tracks, tests, and optimizes online marketing campaigns, providing insights into marketing channel effectiveness.
• Access Control and Collaboration: Facilitates team access and collaboration, organizing marketing data efficiently.
• Click Fraud Monitoring: Identifies and prevents click fraud, saving time and preventing financial losses.
• A/B Testing and Optimization: Enables A/B testing for campaign optimization and improved conversions.
• Customizable Reporting: Supports white-label reporting, maintaining brand consistency in reports.
• Affordability: Offers cost-effective optimization with split testing functionality.
• Web-based Service: No installation required, accessible via web browsers.
• Data Aggregation: Gathers data from diverse marketing channels in one platform.
• A/B Split Testing: Allows A/B testing specifically for landing pages.

• Wide functionality: Keitaro offers various tools for media buying and affiliate marketing, including A/B testing of landings, integration with affiliate programs, and more.
• Flexible traffic processing: The tracker can handle various types of traffic, including clicks from the tracker URL, organic traffic with incoming parameters, and local landing pages without external redirects.
• Automation: Keitaro provides API integrations with popular traffic sources, allowing automatic download of data about advertising campaigns.
• Built-in traffic simulation tool: This feature helps test funnels and filters to ensure they work as intended.
• Protection features: Keitaro has built-in spambot databases, access protection to the admin panel, and compliance with GDPR regulations.
• Advanced tracking capabilities.
• Ability to track multiple traffic sources and conversion events.
• Customizable reporting, allowing users to create custom reports and dashboards.
• Competitive and affordable pricing compared to other tracking solutions.

• Pricing structure can be costlier for larger businesses.
• Limited pricing plans available & pricing not transparent.
• Lacks advanced return rules.
• Doesn't show profit as it doesn't consider the cost of goods.
• Limited tracking capabilities, not compatible with some platforms like Pinterest.
• Limited functionality on mobile, providing only an overview.
• Still in its early stages, lacking a comprehensive refund policy.

• Monthly Subscription: Some features require monthly subscriptions, potentially increasing costs.
• Setup Complexity: Initial setup can be challenging, demanding extra time and effort.
• Limited Trial Period: Trial duration might not be enough for thorough evaluation.
• Lack of Mobile Application: Absence of a mobile app limits on-the-go access.
• Features in Pro Plan: Some advanced features are restricted to Pro plan users.
• Lack of Demo/Tutorial: No video tutorial for user guidance.
• No Live Chat Support: Lack of live chat support for immediate assistance.
• Limited Language Support: Only available in English, limiting non-English users.

• Server version only: Keitaro offers only the server version and does not support OpenVZ servers.
• Frequent system freezes under heavy load: Some users have experienced system freezes when the tracker is under heavy load (NOTE: this can be mitigated by choosing the appropriate server according to your traffic requirements during setup)
• May have a steep learning curve, making it time-consuming for new users to fully understand and utilize all features.
• Limited integrations with third-party tools compared to some competitors.
• Currently, there is no mobile app available for on-the-go tracking.

Attribution:

• Advanced server-side tracking: Bypass iOS14 and ad blockers to limit attribution.
• Gen-2 pixel technology: Accurately track sales back to the correct ad every time.

Event Tracking:

• Track any website, marketing funnel, or online store.
• Track events such as leads, scheduled calls, subscriptions, free trials, purchases, etc., back to the correct ad.
• Automatically send event data back to ad platforms for better ad optimization.

Conversion API:

• Feed accurate data back to ad platforms for conversion optimization.
• Improve ad platform ROAS by passing accurate data to optimize ads.

Comet Ads Manager:

• Advanced ads manager: Turn off losing ads and increase budgets on winning ads.
• Full control of ads management within the Comet Ads Manager.
• Make data-driven decisions to increase ROAS and save time.

Analytics:

• Real-time data updates for quick decision-making.
• Actionable analytics to increase ad performance.

Customer Journeys:

• Allocate marketing dollars correctly by understanding effective touch-points for conversions.
• Identify patterns in customer buying journeys for better marketing efforts.

Coming Soon:

Automations:

• Set rules for auto-optimizing ads and save money on wasted ad spend.
• Get ad decision recommendations from Cometly's AI system.

Spaces:

• Manage unlimited workspaces with accurate ad attribution.
• Ideal for ad agencies to manage multiple clients with Spaces.

Conversion Tracking for Online Marketers

• Track clicks, conversions, and revenue from online marketing in one place.
• Gain insights into conversion origins for optimized marketing strategies.
• Utilize traffic reports to identify successful channels and eliminate ineffective traffic.
• Access segments and metrics like Channel, Referrer, Landing Page, and more.
• Custom-built funnel reports reveal user pathways and drop-off points.
• Automatic customer profiles with insights into behavior and value.
• Built-in A/B Split Testing tools and click fraud monitoring.
• Real-time report updates, export to Excel CSV, and import data.
• Developer API for custom tracking.

PPC Click Fraud Monitoring and Detection

• Prevent financial losses due to fraudulent clicks on paid ads.
• Detect excessive non-converting clicks and repetitive clicks from competitors.
• State-of-the-art monitoring system inspects ad clicks 24/7.
• Recover lost money by preparing detailed fraud reports.
• Impress upon competitors the risk of being caught.
• Access comprehensive information about suspicious clicks.
• Utilize IP WHOIS Lookup for IP address insights.
• Export data to Excel CSV and import commissions from affiliate networks.

Keyword & Conversion Pixel Tracking for Affiliate Marketers

• Professional tools for tracking commissions and campaigns.
• Identify commission sources without separate referral links.
• Safeguard campaigns with link cloaking on ad networks.
• Cloak affiliate links to hide destinations from visitors.
• Integrate with major affiliate networks and programs.
• Compatible with Google Analytics UTM tags.
• Supported networks include Commission Junction, ClickBank, and more.

White-Label Marketing Reports for Agencies

• Elevate client satisfaction and revenue with white-label reports.
• Provide centralized monitoring for all client marketing efforts.
• Incorporate click fraud monitoring to safeguard ad budgets.
• Offer branded access to Improvely reports.
• Pay for one account and serve unlimited clients.
• Customize access levels and services for clients.
• Export reports to Excel CSV and import data.
• Import PPC costs and commissions from affiliate networks.

Flexible Traffic Handling:

• Track any kind of traffic, including clicks, organic traffic with parameters like keyword or search engine.
• Local landing pages with built-in editor for local landings without external redirects.
• Split testing for A/B testing of streams/landings/offers to find the most profitable bundle.
• Traffic Simulation tool to test funnels and flow filters.

Redirects and Actions:

• Five built-in redirects (302, JS, Meta, CURL, custom) to direct traffic.
• Choose actions for traffic flow, like showing a 404 page or output HTML container.
• Receiving and transmitting click parameters with up to 32 cells.

Accurate Traffic Filtering:

• Over 30 internal filters to accept only targeted clicks.
• Customizable filters with provided templates.

Capping Offers:

• Automatically switch traffic to other offers when conversion limits are reached.

Reports and Data Analytics:

• Bug tracking logs and incoming events for error tracing.
• Interactive real-time dashboard with actionable insights.
• Multicurrency support and export reports to Excel/CSV.
• Manual cost upload and customizable reports with filters and metrics.

Automation:

• Automatic costs uploading from popular traffic sources like Facebook, TikTok, GoogleAds.
• Ready-made API integrations for data on advertising campaigns.
• GEO profiles for filtering traffic.
• Click API for remote campaign execution.

Protection:

• Built-in spam bots databases with custom values.
• Admin Dashboard protection with specific domain access.
• GDPR compliant mode.
• Built-in Fail2ban service for server protection.
• Keitaro Geo DB for audience geo data.
• Full IPv6 support.

Postbacks:

• Rebill and Reject sales with unique transaction numbers.
• Income conversions with different statuses (lead, sale, upsale, etc.).
• S2S Postbacks for third-party service integration.

API Integrations:

• Cometly API: Send enriched events from any data source using Cometly's API.
• Zapier: Send events from any application using Zapier.

Ad Channels Integrations:

• Meta: Accurately track campaign performance for all Meta platforms.
• Google Adwords: Attribute revenue back to the correct Google ads.
• Facebook: Attribute revenue back to the correct Facebook ad.
• Instagram: Attribute revenue back to the correct Instagram ad.
• LinkedIn: Attribute revenue back to the correct LinkedIn ad.
• TikTok: Attribute revenue back to the correct TikTok ad.

Ecommerce Integrations:

• Shopify: Sync all orders and attribute purchases to the correct ad.
• WooCommerce: Use the plugin to accurately attribute purchases to ads.
• Magento: Use the API to accurately attribute purchases to the correct ads.
• ClickFunnels: Attribute ClickFunnels orders and upsells to the correct ads.
• Funnelish: Attribute Funnelish orders and upsells to the correct ads.
• ClickBank: Sync ClickBank orders and attribute purchases to the correct ads.
• BuyGoods: Attribute BuyGoods orders and upsells to the correct ads.
• Maxweb: Attribute Maxweb orders and upsells to the correct ads.

B2B Integrations:

• HubSpot: Attribute deal revenue and sync lead qualification (MQL & SQL).
• Salesforce: Attribute deal revenue and sync lead qualification (MQL & SQL).

Coming Soon Integrations:

• Pinterest: Attribute revenue back to the correct Pinterest ad.
• Bing: Attribute revenue back to the correct Bing ad.

👉 Read more about Cometly Integrations here.

Ecommerce Platforms:

• WooCommerce
• Shopify
• Volusion
• BigCommerce

Email Marketing:

• MailChimp

👉 Read more about Improvely Integrations here.

Advertising Networks:

• Built-in integration APIs with advertising networks like Google Ads or Facebook for automatic ad campaign cost tracking.

Cloudflare:

• Turn on Cloudflare Proxy with a single click to maximize landing page protection.

Namecheap:

• Rapidly buy and configure domains directly from Keitaro using the Namecheap integration to save time on launching new advertising campaigns.

Bot Protection Services:

• Use third-party spam databases for additional click checking to prevent bots and spam.

👉 Read more about Keitaro Integrations here.

Cloud Hosted	✅
Self Hosted	❌
Mobile App (Apple)	❌
Mobile App (Android)	❌
Chrome / Browser Extension	❌
API (Open Link)	✅

Cloud Hosted	✅
Self Hosted	❌
Mobile App (Apple)	❌
Mobile App (Android)	❌
Chrome / Browser Extension	❌
API (Open Link)	✅

Cloud Hosted	✅
Self Hosted	❌
Mobile App (Apple)	❌
Mobile App (Android)	❌
Chrome / Browser Extension	❌
API (Open Link)	✅

Price (per Month)	$199 - $499
Free Plan	❌
Trial	❌
Demo	✅
Pricing Link	(Open Link)

Price (per Month)	$29 - $299+
Free Plan	❌
Trial	✅
Demo	✅
Pricing Link	(Open Link)

Price (per Month)	$54 - $142
Price (per Year)	$44 - $114
Free Plan	❌
Trial	✅
Demo	❌
Pricing Link	(Open Link)

• Blog: (Open Link)

• YouTube: (Open Link)

• Docs & Knowledge Base: (Open Link)

• Tutorials: (Open Link)

• Knowledge Hub: (Open Link)

• Blog: (Open Link)

• Docs & Knowledge Base: (Open Link)

• Knowledge Hub: (Open Link)

• Blog: (Open Link)

• YouTube: (Open Link)

• Docs & Knowledge Base: (Open Link)

• Tutorials: (Open Link)

• Knowledge Hub: (Open Link)

What is Cometly?

Cometly is a leading marketing attribution software that provides accurate revenue attribution from ads, empowering marketing teams to make better decisions and optimize campaigns for profitability.

How does Cometly work?

Cometly connects your data sources to accurately track events back to the correct ad using Gen-2 pixel technology, eliminating wasted ad spend and fueling growth. It streamlines ad attribution, allowing you to focus on optimizing and scaling your ads profitably.

Who usesCometly?

Cometly is used by marketing teams, ad managers, and businesses of all sizes, trusted by over 2,000 companies to transform marketing and sales data into revenue-generating insights.

What are the key features of Cometly?

Cometly offers a range of features, including accurate ad tracking, customer journey analysis, Comet Ads Manager for ad optimization, event tracking, Conversion API for improved ad ROAS, and real-time analytics on any ad.

How does Cometly help improve ROI?

By providing hyper-accurate ad attribution, Cometly helps marketing teams measure and prove ROI confidently. Businesses can allocate marketing budget more efficiently, justify scaling up ad campaigns, and focus on the most profitable channels.

Can Cometly save time for marketing teams?

Yes, Cometly users typically save more than 2 hours per day when reviewing ad data and making informed decisions, enabling them to focus on crafting and launching captivating ads to boost revenue.

Does Cometly help save money on ad spend?

Absolutely! Cometly identifies which ads are generating profits and which ones are underperforming, allowing businesses to reduce wasted ad spend and scale successful ads for better returns.

Does Cometly automate data analysis?

Yes, Cometly eliminates the need for manual data entry and time-consuming spreadsheets by automating the reporting process, providing real-time visualizations of marketing performance.

How does Cometly support ad optimization?

Cometly's direct partner integration with ad platforms allows users to turn off underperforming ads or adjust budgets directly from within the platform, enabling faster and more efficient ad optimization.

What is the onboarding process like for Cometly?

Cometly offers a streamlined onboarding experience, seamlessly connecting all ad platforms and data sources, so you can quickly start making data-driven decisions based on your ad performance.

What is Improvely and what does it offer?

Improvely is a comprehensive platform designed to enhance your online marketing efforts. It provides tools for conversion tracking, click fraud monitoring, and more, allowing you to optimize your campaigns and protect your advertising budget.

How does Improvely's dashboard simplify tracking?

Improvely offers an easy-to-use dashboard that consolidates all your marketing endeavors in one place. This simplifies the process of tracking and attributing conversions to their source, providing you with valuable insights into the effectiveness of your various marketing channels.

What does "Built To Optimize Your Marketing" mean?

Improvely excels in attribution by identifying the origin of each signup and sale, whether they stem from a marketing campaign or any other channel. This feature allows you to optimize your marketing strategies with laser-focused accuracy based on real-time data.

How does Improvely address click fraud?

Improvely's built-in click fraud monitoring employs cutting-edge systems to inspect every click for signs of suspicious activity. When potential click fraud is detected, you receive instant alerts, empowering you to take swift action and protect your advertising budget from wasteful clicks.

How does Improvely help in understanding customers?

Improvely assists in understanding your audience by creating activity profiles for each visitor to your site. This way, you can gain insights into the behavior of your most valuable customers, enabling you to tailor your strategies to better connect with them and attract similar audiences.

Can Improvely be used collaboratively?

Yes, Improvely is designed to accommodate various organizational needs. It offers features like team logins, custom-branded client reports, and export tools, facilitating seamless collaboration whether you work alone or with a team or clients.

How compatible is Improvely with different advertising platforms?

Improvely works everywhere you advertise online, ensuring compatibility with all major online advertising platforms. This means you can seamlessly integrate it into your existing marketing strategies, regardless of the platforms you use.

What's the advantage of using Improvely over other analytics tools?

Many users have found Improvely to be highly effective and efficient. Jim Belosic, CEO of Shortstack, stated that they've spent thousands of dollars trying to get Google Analytics to do 10% of what Improvely accomplishes.

How can I try out Improvely?

You can try Improvely for free with a 14-day trial. This gives you the opportunity to explore its features and see how it can enhance your online marketing efforts without any upfront cost.

How can I learn more about Improvely's features and capabilities?

To learn more about Improvely's features, you can explore its interactive demo, as well as access resources such as its product blog and knowledge base. Additionally, you can get in touch with their team through the Contact Us section for any further inquiries.

What is Keitaro™?

Keitaro is an ultimate advertising tracker designed specifically for media buyers and publishers to optimize, control, and protect their traffic in the affiliate and performance marketing industry.

How does Keitaro benefit advertisers and publishers?

Keitaro enables advertisers and publishers to reduce costs for unprofitable advertising campaigns and focus on generating profits by providing minute-to-minute updated data and efficient conversions attribution.

How many traffic sources is Keitaro integrated with?

Keitaro is integrated with more than 120 traffic sources, making it easy for users to connect to various external platforms for seamless data collection and analysis.

What are the key features of Keitaro?

Some key features of Keitaro include traffic distribution on user's terms, setting up hundreds of landing pages and redirects, customizable reports for millions of clicks, protection from bots with a built-in bot database, and access to more than 250 affiliate network templates.

How can Keitaro help improve teamwork in affiliate marketing?

For clients working with mobile apps and dealing with large teams, Keitaro offers access levels configured for each role, ensuring flexible and effective teamwork for successful account farming, setting up bundles, and media buying.

Why is Keitaro recommended for multi-offer landing pages?

Keitaro's built-in set of tools is the best solution for working with multi-offer landing pages, common in industries like Nutra and Financial offers, as it helps track individual offer effectiveness and increase conversion rates.

How does Keitaro contribute to advertising optimization and cost reduction?

Keitaro's ability to test many approaches simultaneously and handle huge volumes of traffic efficiently allows affiliate marketers to find profitable bundles early, resulting in significant budget savings and higher ROI.

Is Keitaro compliant with data protection regulations?

Yes, Keitaro is fully committed to complying with all relevant data protection legal requirements, including the GDPR and CCPA, ensuring privacy rights are respected.

What do users say about Keitaro?

Keitaro is praised by users as a reliable and stable traffic tracking solution, providing optimized performance even on low-end hardware. The support team is responsive and helps users find the best solutions.

How can users get started with Keitaro?

Users can start taking full advantage of Keitaro by creating an account and exploring its features, including GDPR compliance, Keitaro 10, resources, and a referral program, to enhance their performance marketing strategies.