⭐ ClickMagick vs Heylink vs Keitaro

ClickMagick is an unparalleled tracking and attribution platform, offering GDPR compliant data to optimize ads and sales funnels.

With TrueTracking® technology, it consolidates essential data and insights, catering to entrepreneurs, affiliate marketers, and small businesses.

Its strength lies in seamless integration with major ad platforms and thousands of apps through Zapier.

ClickMagick's advanced multi-touch attribution models provide deeper insights for better campaign optimization.

The platform's commitment to user support, world-class bot filtering, cross-device tracking, and Audience Optimization™ make it a feature-rich and user-friendly solution trusted by thousands of satisfied users worldwide.

Its reasonable pricing and 14-day free trial adds to its appeal.

Read the full ClickMagick Review

👉 Visit ClickMagick

Heylink introduces a new era of affiliate marketing with its all-in-one tool, streamlining affiliate link management and providing full transparency into performance.

Real-time reporting empowers users to optimize campaigns effectively, while smart links maximize commissions.

The platform goes beyond traditional affiliate marketing, identifying untapped revenue opportunities.

Heylink's cookieless tracking methods and data customization options make it suitable for various platforms.

However, the lack of negative reviews hinders user satisfaction assessment, and the absence of listed integrations with other software may limit compatibility.

Overall, Heylink is a comprehensive toolbox for affiliate publishers seeking growth and success.

Read the full Heylink Review

👉 Visit Heylink

Keitaro™ is a powerful advertising tracker designed for media buyers and publishers in the affiliate marketing industry.

With over 120 integrated traffic sources, it offers minute-to-minute data updates, customizable reports, and efficient conversions attribution, leading to cost reduction and better decision-making.

Notable features include traffic distribution on user terms, multi-offer landing pages, and GDPR compliance.

Users praise its seamless integration, protection from bots, and advertising optimization capabilities.

While it lacks a mobile app and has a learning curve, Keitaro remains a comprehensive and reliable solution, offering wide functionality and competitive pricing in the performance marketing landscape.

Read the full Keitaro Review

👉 Visit Keitaro

The target audience for ClickMagick is entrepreneurs, affiliate marketers, ecommerce stores, and small businesses seeking an unbeatable tracking and attribution platform to optimize their ads and sales funnels.

The target audience for Heylink is affiliate marketers and businesses seeking to optimize their affiliate marketing efforts and improve revenue attribution.

The target audience for Keitaro is media buyers and publishers in the affiliate and performance marketing industry.

• Reasonable Prices: Competitive pricing, starting from $49/month.
• Overall Tool: Suitable for digital marketers including affiliate marketers.
• Free Trial: Free trial service available for beginners, 14-day free trial without limits
• Data Retention: Allows retaining data from 6 months to years, suitable for long-term marketing.
• User Interface: User-friendly and easy to use, though UX/UI may need improvement.
• Advanced Features: Parallel tracking, Advanced tracking, Complete sales funnel tracking, UTM and first-party cookies, Automatic bot filtering, Traffic scoring, Sub-IDs, Geotargeting/Mobile Optimization, Cross-platform conversion tracking, Fully integrated with Facebook's Conversion API, Real-time stats, Automated split testing, Track every ad on various platforms, Link rotation, Funnel builder tool, Postback URL functionality, Batch editor feature.
• Customer Support: Provides good support, solving queries within 24 hours, Excellent support and documentation, Incredibly Helpful Support or “Knowledge Base”, 1-hour fast support system in place, Extensive knowledgebase with over 400 articles and tutorials.
• Real-time Updates: Real-time updates and mobile notifications, 24/7 uptime, Real-time mobile updates, notifications, and metrics.
• Compatibility: Compatibility with Google Analytics and other SEO tools, Integrates with Google Ads, Cross-device tracking, Tracks iOS users.
• Custom Domain: Customizable domains, Unlimited custom domains.
• Saviour Feature: Notifies if affiliate links are working, allowing prevention of losses.
• Other Features: Numerous features to optimize links and improve ROI, ClickShield to reduce wasted ad spend, Track & Optimize Your Entire Sales Funnel, 24/7 Click-Fraud & Link Monitoring, Works Everywhere You Advertise, Bulletproof Cross-Device Tracking, Ability to track offline conversions, "Personalized" documentation, Phone and offline sales tracking, Quality support, Comprehensive and highly flexible features, True cross-device tracking, 30-day money-back guarantee.

• Offers a single dashboard to track all affiliate data, enhancing content management and ad spending efficiency.
• Provides real-time data and callback features, enabling timely actions and decision-making.
• Automatically adjusts/selects affiliate links, reducing broken links and removing the need for manual adjustments.
• Identifies monetization opportunities for valuable clicks sent to advertisers not running campaigns, boosting revenue.
• Comprehensive toolbox for affiliate publishers, delivering actionable insights to increase revenue.
• Helps publishers address challenges like tracking campaigns across multiple networks, manual link management, and identifying new opportunities.

• Wide functionality: Keitaro offers various tools for media buying and affiliate marketing, including A/B testing of landings, integration with affiliate programs, and more.
• Flexible traffic processing: The tracker can handle various types of traffic, including clicks from the tracker URL, organic traffic with incoming parameters, and local landing pages without external redirects.
• Automation: Keitaro provides API integrations with popular traffic sources, allowing automatic download of data about advertising campaigns.
• Built-in traffic simulation tool: This feature helps test funnels and filters to ensure they work as intended.
• Protection features: Keitaro has built-in spambot databases, access protection to the admin panel, and compliance with GDPR regulations.
• Advanced tracking capabilities.
• Ability to track multiple traffic sources and conversion events.
• Customizable reporting, allowing users to create custom reports and dashboards.
• Competitive and affordable pricing compared to other tracking solutions.

• Limited Payment Options: Only available to Credit Card owners.
• Policy Violation Restrictions: Cannot promote certain services like crypto, adult services, etc.
• Not for Beginners: Despite good UI, not suitable for newcomers, learning curve for newcomers due to the wide range of features.
• No Free Plan Available: Limited 14-day trial period, Need to enter card details for access to the free trial.
• Issues for Small Websites & Beginners: Not suitable for small websites with little traffic, not ideal for beginners in click tracking tools.
• UX/UI: Needs improvement for better understanding of the features, especially for newbies who may rely heavily on text documentations.

• No negative reviews available, making it challenging to determine user satisfaction and reliability.
• Lacks integrations with other software or services, potentially limiting compatibility with existing workflows.
• Integrations with different affiliate networks and platforms not listed on website.

• Server version only: Keitaro offers only the server version and does not support OpenVZ servers.
• Frequent system freezes under heavy load: Some users have experienced system freezes when the tracker is under heavy load (NOTE: this can be mitigated by choosing the appropriate server according to your traffic requirements during setup)
• May have a steep learning curve, making it time-consuming for new users to fully understand and utilize all features.
• Limited integrations with third-party tools compared to some competitors.
• Currently, there is no mobile app available for on-the-go tracking.

Tracking: Powerful Ad Tracking and Conversion Attribution Solution

• Single Source of Truth: ClickMagick serves as a unified platform for viewing all key marketing metrics and actual results.
• 5-Minute Set Up: Users can enable tracking for websites or online stores by simply copying and pasting a bit of tracking code.
• Compatibility: ClickMagick works with all traffic sources, ad networks, website builders, autoresponders, CRMs, etc.
• Custom Postbacks / Webhooks: Enables automatic sending of conversion data to other platforms and apps.

Optimization: Helps Optimize Ad Campaigns and Other Promotions

• TrueTracking®: Enhances the optimization of ad campaigns by providing precise tracking information.
• Zapier Integration: Allows data to be sent to thousands of additional apps for more robust optimization.
• API Access: Full ClickMagick API gives almost unlimited flexibility to build custom tools and automations.

Anti-Fraud: Provides Protection Against Bot and Click Fraud

• Bot & Click Fraud Protection: ClickMagick offers features to safeguard against fraudulent clicks, ensuring that ad data remains accurate and trustworthy.

Affiliates: Offers Tools for Affiliate Marketing

• Affiliate Marketing Tools: Designed specifically for affiliate marketers, these tools assist in tracking, reporting, and optimizing affiliate marketing efforts.

Tools: Various Other Tools to Enhance Marketing Efforts

• Campaign Wizard and URL Builder: Guides users in tracking ad campaigns and other promotions properly.
• Custom Tools Development: The REST API provides the ability to create custom tools for unique business needs.

Connect: Works with Various Marketing Apps and Platforms

• Integration with Marketing Apps: Plays well with other marketing tools and applications in your stack, ensuring seamless connection.
• Shareable Public Stats: Allows for sharing stats with internal teams or providing statistics to someone who has purchased traffic.
• Collaboration Tools: Enables inviting team members to collaborate within your ClickMagick account with various access levels.

Support: Dedicated Customer Support and Training

• Dedicated Support Team: Quick and competent support for users, including detailed assistance in setup.
• Positive User Testimonials: Many users have praised the support team's responsiveness and effectiveness.
• On-the-Go Access: ClickMagick is available on both the Google Play Store for Android and the iOS App Store, providing support and accessibility anytime, anywhere.

Affiliate Link Management:

• All-in-one dashboard for tracking affiliate data, providing transparency and ease of management.
• No need to log in to multiple affiliate networks; track all data in a single dashboard for increased efficiency.

Revenue Attribution:

• Compare campaigns and attribute revenue to specific content and links.
• Discover which links convert best based on device, advertiser, or source.

Real-Time Reporting:

• Live data on affiliate performance with no delay, enabling timely actions.
• Real-time callback feature for immediate response to clicks and conversions.

Smart Links:

• Automatically adjust affiliate links to maximize commissions.
• Ensure the highest possible earnings and eliminate broken links.

Revenue Opportunities:

• Identify untapped revenue opportunities by finding valuable clicks that could be monetized with new advertisers.
• Instantly connect with new networks to boost revenue.

Flexible Traffic Handling:

• Track any kind of traffic, including clicks, organic traffic with parameters like keyword or search engine.
• Local landing pages with built-in editor for local landings without external redirects.
• Split testing for A/B testing of streams/landings/offers to find the most profitable bundle.
• Traffic Simulation tool to test funnels and flow filters.

Redirects and Actions:

• Five built-in redirects (302, JS, Meta, CURL, custom) to direct traffic.
• Choose actions for traffic flow, like showing a 404 page or output HTML container.
• Receiving and transmitting click parameters with up to 32 cells.

Accurate Traffic Filtering:

• Over 30 internal filters to accept only targeted clicks.
• Customizable filters with provided templates.

Capping Offers:

• Automatically switch traffic to other offers when conversion limits are reached.

Reports and Data Analytics:

• Bug tracking logs and incoming events for error tracing.
• Interactive real-time dashboard with actionable insights.
• Multicurrency support and export reports to Excel/CSV.
• Manual cost upload and customizable reports with filters and metrics.

Automation:

• Automatic costs uploading from popular traffic sources like Facebook, TikTok, GoogleAds.
• Ready-made API integrations for data on advertising campaigns.
• GEO profiles for filtering traffic.
• Click API for remote campaign execution.

Protection:

• Built-in spam bots databases with custom values.
• Admin Dashboard protection with specific domain access.
• GDPR compliant mode.
• Built-in Fail2ban service for server protection.
• Keitaro Geo DB for audience geo data.
• Full IPv6 support.

Postbacks:

• Rebill and Reject sales with unique transaction numbers.
• Income conversions with different statuses (lead, sale, upsale, etc.).
• S2S Postbacks for third-party service integration.

• Zapier
• API

👉 Read more about ClickMagick Integrations here.

• Server2Server integration
• Simple API callback setup
• Advanced API setup

👉 Read more about Heylink Integrations here.

Advertising Networks:

• Built-in integration APIs with advertising networks like Google Ads or Facebook for automatic ad campaign cost tracking.

Cloudflare:

• Turn on Cloudflare Proxy with a single click to maximize landing page protection.

Namecheap:

• Rapidly buy and configure domains directly from Keitaro using the Namecheap integration to save time on launching new advertising campaigns.

Bot Protection Services:

• Use third-party spam databases for additional click checking to prevent bots and spam.

👉 Read more about Keitaro Integrations here.

Cloud Hosted	✅
Self Hosted	❌
Mobile App (Apple)	✅
Mobile App (Android)	✅
Chrome / Browser Extension	❌
API (Open Link)	✅

Cloud Hosted	✅
Self Hosted	❌
Mobile App (Apple)	❌
Mobile App (Android)	❌
Chrome / Browser Extension	❌
API (Open Link)	✅

Cloud Hosted	✅
Self Hosted	❌
Mobile App (Apple)	❌
Mobile App (Android)	❌
Chrome / Browser Extension	❌
API (Open Link)	✅

Price (per Month)	$49 - $199
Free Plan	❌
Trial	✅
Demo	❌
Pricing Link	(Open Link)

Price (per Month)	$49 - $749
Free Plan	❌
Trial	❌
Demo	✅
Pricing Link	(Open Link)

Price (per Month)	$54 - $142
Price (per Year)	$44 - $114
Free Plan	❌
Trial	✅
Demo	❌
Pricing Link	(Open Link)

• Docs & Knowledge Base: (Open Link)

• Knowledge Hub: (Open Link)

• Blog: (Open Link)

• Docs & Knowledge Base: (Open Link)

• Knowledge Hub: (Open Link)

• Blog: (Open Link)

• YouTube: (Open Link)

• Docs & Knowledge Base: (Open Link)

• Tutorials: (Open Link)

• Knowledge Hub: (Open Link)

How quickly can I set up and integrate ClickMagick into my business?

ClickMagick offers a straightforward setup process, allowing you to integrate it into your business quickly. Simply sign up for an account, follow the on-screen instructions, and you'll be ready to start tracking your links and campaigns.

What if I have a really complicated or custom setup?

ClickMagick is designed to handle various tracking scenarios, including complex and custom setups. If you encounter any challenges, their support team is readily available to guide you through the process.

Should I sign up if I’m brand new to online marketing?

Yes, ClickMagick is an excellent tool for beginners in online marketing. It provides a user-friendly interface and comprehensive resources to help you understand and utilize tracking effectively.

Why can’t I rely on the stats in my ad networks or other apps I use?

Ad networks and other applications may not provide accurate tracking data as they often have limited attribution models. ClickMagick uses advanced tracking techniques, ensuring accurate and reliable data for your campaigns.

So what exactly can I track and optimize with ClickMagick?

ClickMagick allows you to track various metrics, including clicks, conversions, sales, and more. You can optimize your marketing efforts based on real-time data and make data-driven decisions for better results.

I hear people have trouble with “tracking links” and ad networks. What’s the story?

Some ad networks have restrictions on the use of certain tracking links, which can lead to inaccurate data. ClickMagick provides cloaking and other link management features to overcome these limitations and ensure proper tracking.

How does Audience Optimization™ help find me more customers at the lowest cost?

Audience Optimization™ in ClickMagick analyzes your click data to identify the most responsive audiences. It allows you to target these audiences specifically, increasing your chances of finding valuable customers at lower costs.

How will ClickMagick’s Click Shield™ help me save money from day one?

Click Shield™ protects your campaigns from click fraud and non-human bot traffic, saving your budget from wasteful clicks. This feature ensures that you only pay for genuine, valuable clicks.

How does ClickMagick protect me from ""bots"" and other fake clicks?

ClickMagick utilizes advanced algorithms to identify and block bot traffic and fake clicks. This protection ensures that your tracking data remains accurate, and you don't waste money on fraudulent clicks.

What about things like Cross-Device and Offline Sales Tracking... is it hard to set up?

ClickMagick offers easy-to-follow instructions for setting up Cross-Device and Offline Sales Tracking. With proper integration, you can gain insights into the entire customer journey and accurately attribute sales across devices and offline channels.

Is ClickMagick affected by the recent changes with iOS 14.5+?

ClickMagick has adapted to the changes introduced with iOS 14.5+ to ensure accurate tracking for iOS users. They stay up-to-date with platform changes to provide uninterrupted service.

What should I know about tracking iOS users and Google Ads?

ClickMagick offers solutions and recommendations for tracking iOS users' interactions with Google Ads. By following their guidelines, you can maintain accurate tracking and optimize your campaigns effectively.

What should I know about tracking iOS users and Facebook Ads?

ClickMagick provides insights and best practices for tracking iOS users engaging with Facebook Ads. Following their guidelines will ensure that you continue to receive valuable data from your Facebook advertising efforts.

How is ClickMagick different from Google Analytics?

ClickMagick focuses specifically on tracking and optimizing marketing campaigns, while Google Analytics provides broader website analytics. ClickMagick offers features tailored to marketers, such as link tracking, conversion attribution, and click fraud protection.

How does ClickMagick compare to its competitors?

ClickMagick stands out due to its user-friendly interface, advanced tracking capabilities, and responsive customer support. It consistently receives positive reviews from users for its effectiveness and ease of use.

Why is ClickMagick so affordable compared to other options?

ClickMagick prioritizes accessibility and affordability for all types of marketers. They believe that every business should have access to accurate tracking, regardless of their budget.

Does Heylink use cookies for tracking?

No, Heylink does not use cookies for tracking. It employs 7 different tracking methods, making cookieless tracking possible. For Affiliate network Campaigns, Heylink tracks clicks on your website and retrieves conversion data from the networks, without requiring any Personal Identifier Information (PII). For Direct Partnerships, where tracking occurs on both your website and the partner's webshop, Heylink tracks the click ID on your website and matches it with the Conversion ID on the partner's webshop, also without using PII.

Is using cookies for tracking optional in Heylink?

Yes, it's optional. If you want to collect external Marketing tags, you can use 1 cookie called "_hey". This cookie saves Referrer URL and external Marketing Tags like Google Click ID's, Facebook IDs, and custom UTM parameters. However, if you choose to collect external Marketing Tags via Heylink, you must obtain visitor consent for "Marketing and Statistical data" based on your specific requirements.

How often is my data updated in Heylink?

The data in Heylink is continuously updated in real-time, ensuring you have access to the latest insights and information.

Can I track data for direct partnerships that don't run through an affiliate network?

Yes, you can track data for direct partnerships without involving an affiliate network. Heylink's tracking capabilities allow you to monitor clicks and conversions even in direct partnerships, without the need for an intermediary network.

Can I see the entire journey of my conversions?

Yes, Heylink provides a comprehensive view of the entire conversion journey. From the initial click on your website to the final conversion on the partner's webshop, you can track and analyze the complete path of each conversion.

Can I use Heylink for data collection only?

Yes, Heylink's "Discover mode" enables data collection without automation or optimization. In "Discover mode," Heylink logs clicks on your site, providing valuable data to assess the potential for monetization before fully enabling Heylink's features.

Will Heylink show me links that I'm not currently monetizing?

Yes, Heylink's platform displays all your links, even those not currently monetized. This feature allows you to identify untapped monetization opportunities and optimize your strategies accordingly.

Can I use Heylink on TikTok/Instagram/Facebook/Newsletters?

Yes, you can use Heylink on various platforms, including TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, and Newsletters. Heylink's tracking and monitoring capabilities extend to these platforms, enabling you to manage and analyze affiliate links effectively.

I can't find an affiliate network that I am using in your system, how can I connect it?

Heylink regularly adds new Network integrations to its system. If you have a specific Network that you would like to be added, you can contact Heylink's support team at [email protected], and they will assist you in connecting the desired affiliate network.

Can I use Heylink for free?

Yes, Heylink offers a Freemium version that provides access to all features. With the Freemium version, you can add an unlimited number of users and websites. However, there are some limitations: commissions up to $2,500, one Network integration, and records (pageviews, clicks, and conversions) capped at 50,000 with historical data available for 6 months. If you require additional capabilities, you can explore Heylink's pricing plans to choose the one that best suits your needs.

How many users can I add to my Heylink account?

You can add an unlimited number of users to your Heylink account. From your profile settings, you can invite and manage new users efficiently.

Can I choose which currency I see the data in?

Yes, Heylink allows you to select the currency in which you want to view the data. This customization ensures you can understand and analyze your performance in your preferred currency.

What is Keitaro™?

Keitaro is an ultimate advertising tracker designed specifically for media buyers and publishers to optimize, control, and protect their traffic in the affiliate and performance marketing industry.

How does Keitaro benefit advertisers and publishers?

Keitaro enables advertisers and publishers to reduce costs for unprofitable advertising campaigns and focus on generating profits by providing minute-to-minute updated data and efficient conversions attribution.

How many traffic sources is Keitaro integrated with?

Keitaro is integrated with more than 120 traffic sources, making it easy for users to connect to various external platforms for seamless data collection and analysis.

What are the key features of Keitaro?

Some key features of Keitaro include traffic distribution on user's terms, setting up hundreds of landing pages and redirects, customizable reports for millions of clicks, protection from bots with a built-in bot database, and access to more than 250 affiliate network templates.

How can Keitaro help improve teamwork in affiliate marketing?

For clients working with mobile apps and dealing with large teams, Keitaro offers access levels configured for each role, ensuring flexible and effective teamwork for successful account farming, setting up bundles, and media buying.

Why is Keitaro recommended for multi-offer landing pages?

Keitaro's built-in set of tools is the best solution for working with multi-offer landing pages, common in industries like Nutra and Financial offers, as it helps track individual offer effectiveness and increase conversion rates.

How does Keitaro contribute to advertising optimization and cost reduction?

Keitaro's ability to test many approaches simultaneously and handle huge volumes of traffic efficiently allows affiliate marketers to find profitable bundles early, resulting in significant budget savings and higher ROI.

Is Keitaro compliant with data protection regulations?

Yes, Keitaro is fully committed to complying with all relevant data protection legal requirements, including the GDPR and CCPA, ensuring privacy rights are respected.

What do users say about Keitaro?

Keitaro is praised by users as a reliable and stable traffic tracking solution, providing optimized performance even on low-end hardware. The support team is responsive and helps users find the best solutions.

How can users get started with Keitaro?

Users can start taking full advantage of Keitaro by creating an account and exploring its features, including GDPR compliance, Keitaro 10, resources, and a referral program, to enhance their performance marketing strategies.